Edward Elric vs Alphonse Elric Which Fullmetal Alchemist Brother Makes the Best Collectable

Edward Elric vs Alphonse Elric: Which Fullmetal Alchemist Brother Makes the Best Collectable?

Matthew Wrightson Matthew Wrightson
14 minute read

Listen to article
Audio generated by DropInBlog's Blog Voice AI™ may have slight pronunciation nuances. Learn more

When it comes to Fullmetal Alchemist, choosing a favourite Elric brother isn't easy. You've got Edward, the fiery young State Alchemist with an unforgettable red coat, and Alphonse, the gentle giant whose soul lives inside a suit of armour. Both have captured the hearts of anime fans, but which brother makes the better collectable?

Now, you don't have to choose between their adventures and alchemical abilities. Edward and Alphonse have both joined the TUBBZ collection, transforming into officially licensed cosplaying rubber ducks. Each figure captures the brothers' recognisable appearances while adding the playful twist that makes TUBBZ so distinctive.

With Collector's, Boxed and Mini Editions available for both characters, there's plenty for Fullmetal Alchemist fans to explore. But if you're deciding which figure deserves the first spot on your shelf, it's worth looking at what makes each brother special. From their character designs and personalities to their collectable appeal, let's compare Edward Elric and Alphonse Elric to find out who comes out on top!

Key Takeaways

  • Edward Elric stands out with his signature blond hair, red coat and fiery personality, making him an excellent choice for fans of Fullmetal Alchemist himself.
  • Alphonse Elric offers a distinctive collectable design featuring his iconic steel armour and helmet, making him particularly appealing to fans of his character.
  • Both brothers are available in Collector's, Boxed and Mini Editions, with each Collector's Edition limited to just 1,000 pieces worldwide.

Meet the Elric Brothers: What Makes Edward and Alphonse Different?

Before comparing their TUBBZ figures, it's worth understanding why these two characters are so popular. Edward and Alphonse Elric are at the heart of Fullmetal Alchemist, a manga and anime franchise created by Hiromu Arakawa. Their journey begins with a forbidden attempt at human transmutation. After losing their mother, the brothers try to bring her back using alchemy, but the experiment goes terribly wrong. Edward loses his right arm and left leg, while Alphonse loses his entire physical body.

Determined to reverse what happened, the brothers set out to find the Philosopher's Stone. Their journey becomes a story about family, sacrifice, friendship and the consequences of ambition. Although they share the same goal, Edward and Alphonse have very different personalities and appearances. These differences are also what make their TUBBZ collectables so interesting.

Fullmetal Alchemist: Edward Elric TUBBZ (Collector's Edition)

€24,99

The Fullmetal Alchemist is ready to put his alchemy skills to the test as Edward Elric joins the TUBBZ Collector’s Edition range. Reimagined as a cosplaying duck, Ed keeps his unmistakable blond hair, red coat and determined expression, capturing the… read more

Fullmetal Alchemist: Edward Elric TUBBZ (Collector's Edition)

Edward Elric: The Fiery Fullmetal Alchemist

Edward Elric is the older brother and one of the youngest State Alchemists in the history of Amestris. Known as the Fullmetal Alchemist, he's intelligent, determined and incredibly skilled at using alchemy.

His personality is just as memorable as his abilities. Edward can be stubborn, impatient and quick-tempered, but beneath that fiery exterior is someone who cares deeply about his family and friends. His signature appearance includes blond hair, a long red coat and his distinctive automail limbs. These details make him instantly recognisable, even outside the world of Fullmetal Alchemist.

Fullmetal Alchemist: Alphonse Elric TUBBZ (Collector's Edition)

€24,99

Alphonse Elric may have lost his human body, but his imposing armour makes the transition to TUBBZ perfectly. The younger Elric brother appears in his distinctive steel armour, complete with the instantly recognisable helmet and details inspired by his appearance… read more

Fullmetal Alchemist: Alphonse Elric TUBBZ (Collector's Edition)

Alphonse Elric: The Gentle Giant in Armour

Alphonse Elric is Edward's younger brother, and his appearance couldn't be more different. Following the failed human transmutation, his soul becomes attached to a suit of armour, giving him one of the most recognisable designs in anime.

Despite his imposing appearance, Alphonse is gentle, patient and compassionate. He's often the calmer voice between the two brothers, balancing Edward's fiery personality with his own thoughtful approach. His distinctive steel armour and iconic helmet make him an excellent character for a collectable figure. It's also a design that translates particularly well into the TUBBZ format.

Edward Elric vs Alphonse Elric: Comparing Their TUBBZ Designs

So, which brother has the more impressive TUBBZ transformation? Both figures bring something different to the collection, largely because of their contrasting original designs. Edward's collectable focuses on his recognisable outfit and confident personality, while Alphonse's version celebrates his unmistakable armoured appearance.

Let's compare their defining features.

Fullmetal Alchemist: Edward Elric TUBBZ (Mini Edition)

€9,99

Edward Elric proves you don’t need to be tall to be a legendary State Alchemist. The Fullmetal Alchemist gets an even smaller TUBBZ transformation for this Mini Edition, retaining his signature blond hair, red coat and unmistakable attitude.  Compact but… read more

Fullmetal Alchemist: Edward Elric TUBBZ (Mini Edition)

Edward Elric TUBBZ: Red Coat and Alchemical Attitude

Edward's TUBBZ figure captures the familiar appearance of the Fullmetal Alchemist, featuring his signature blond hair, distinctive red coat and determined expression. The design retains the character details that fans immediately associate with Edward, bringing his fiery personality into the playful world of cosplaying rubber ducks. If you enjoy collecting characters with colourful designs and instantly recognisable outfits, Edward is a particularly appealing choice.

Fullmetal Alchemist: Alphonse Elric TUBBZ (Mini Edition)

€9,99

Alphonse Elric’s towering suit of armour has been given a much smaller makeover for this TUBBZ Mini Edition. His familiar helmet and armoured appearance remain instantly recognisable, bringing the gentle younger Elric brother to the collection in compact form.  Mini… read more

Fullmetal Alchemist: Alphonse Elric TUBBZ (Mini Edition)

Alphonse Elric TUBBZ: Armour With a Quacking Twist

Alphonse takes a very different approach. His TUBBZ figure recreates the distinctive steel armour and helmet that have become synonymous with the character. While Edward's design stands out through his red coat and blond hair, Alphonse's armoured appearance gives him a completely different visual identity. His imposing design also makes him an interesting addition to an anime display, particularly when placed alongside Edward.

Side-by-Side Character Comparison

FeatureEdward ElricAlphonse Elric
Character roleOlder brother and State AlchemistYounger brother and armoured alchemist
Signature appearanceBlond hair and red coatSteel armour and distinctive helmet
PersonalityFiery, determined and stubbornGentle, patient and compassionate
TUBBZ design appealColourful and instantly recognisableDistinctive and armour-focused
Best suited toFans of Fullmetal AlchemistFans of the armoured brother
Display appealAdds colour to your collectionCreates a striking visual contrast

The verdict: Edward is a great choice if you love his iconic outfit and energetic personality. Alphonse is equally appealing if you prefer distinctive character designs and his unforgettable armoured appearance. Neither figure is an obvious winner because they offer two very different interpretations of the same beloved franchise.

Exploring the Six Elric Brothers TUBBZ Collectables

One of the best things about this collection is that you don't have to settle for just one version of your favourite brother. Edward and Alphonse are both available in three editions, giving you six individual collectables to explore.

Whether you're interested in limited releases, stylish packaging or smaller figures, let's take a closer look at your options.

1. Edward Elric Collector's Edition

If you're a fan of the Fullmetal Alchemist himself, the Edward Elric Collector's Edition is an excellent addition to consider. Featuring his signature blond hair, distinctive red coat and determined expression, this collectable brings his familiar appearance into the signature TUBBZ bathtub display packaging.

What makes it particularly appealing is its limited production run of just 1,000 pieces worldwide. This makes it a great choice for collectors who enjoy limited-edition anime merchandise.

2. Alphonse Elric Collector's Edition

The Alphonse Elric Collector's Edition brings the armoured brother into the TUBBZ collection, complete with his recognisable steel armour and distinctive helmet. Like Edward's version, it comes in signature bathtub display packaging and has a strictly limited production run of just 1,000 pieces worldwide.

Its unique appearance makes it a particularly interesting addition to an anime display. Better still, collecting both Collector's Editions allows you to bring the legendary brothers together in limited-edition form.

Fullmetal Alchemist: Edward Elric TUBBZ (Boxed Edition)

€19,99

Edward Elric has performed another remarkable transformation, this time becoming a cosplaying duck for the TUBBZ range. His blond hair, distinctive red coat and famously fierce expression make the Fullmetal Alchemist instantly recognisable, even in this unexpected form.  From his… read more

Fullmetal Alchemist: Edward Elric TUBBZ (Boxed Edition)

3. Edward Elric Boxed Edition

Prefer a stylish display option? The Edward Elric Boxed Edition offers another way to welcome the Fullmetal Alchemist into your collection. Featuring his recognisable red coat, blond hair and fierce expression, this collectable comes in stylish collector's display packaging. It's a great choice if you want to showcase Edward alongside other anime figures or create a dedicated Fullmetal Alchemist display.

Fullmetal Alchemist: Alphonse Elric TUBBZ (Boxed Edition)

€19,99

Alphonse Elric trades his imposing stature for a more compact TUBBZ transformation, while keeping the armoured appearance that makes him instantly recognisable. His distinctive helmet and steel body have been recreated in cosplaying duck form, giving the younger Elric brother… read more

Fullmetal Alchemist: Alphonse Elric TUBBZ (Boxed Edition)

4. Alphonse Elric Boxed Edition

The Alphonse Elric Boxed Edition brings his distinctive armoured appearance into the TUBBZ range. His familiar helmet and steel armour make this figure instantly recognisable, while the stylish display box offers a neat way to showcase him alongside your other collectables. Pair him with Edward's Boxed Edition to create a display celebrating the brothers' unforgettable relationship.

5. Edward Elric Mini Edition

Big alchemical ambitions come in small packages! The Edward Elric Mini Edition offers a compact version of the famous State Alchemist, retaining his signature blond hair, red coat and unmistakable attitude. Its smaller format makes it ideal for collectors with limited display space or anyone who enjoys collecting miniature toys and figures.

6. Alphonse Elric Mini Edition

Completing the miniature pairing is the Alphonse Elric Mini Edition. His familiar steel-armoured appearance and distinctive helmet have been recreated in a smaller collectable format. It's a great choice if you want to bring both brothers together without taking up too much display space. Place Edward and Alphonse side by side to create a compact Fullmetal Alchemist display.

Collector's vs Boxed vs Mini: Which Brother's Edition Should You Choose?

Choosing between Edward and Alphonse is only part of the decision. You'll also need to consider which edition best suits your collecting preferences. Both characters are available in the same three formats, so the choice largely comes down to packaging, display space and your interest in limited collectables.

EditionEdward ElricAlphonse ElricBest For
Collector'sLimited to 1,000 worldwideLimited to 1,000 worldwideLimited-edition collectors
BoxedStylish collector's display boxStylish collector's display boxDisplay-focused collectors
MiniCompact collectable formatCompact collectable formatSmaller collections

Which Collector's Edition Is Best?

If you're interested in limited-edition collectables, both Collector's Editions deserve a place on your shortlist.

Edward's red coat and blond hair create a colourful display piece, while Alphonse's steel armour offers something visually different. With just 1,000 of each character available worldwide, collecting both gives you the opportunity to own the complete limited-edition pairing.

Should You Choose the Boxed Editions?

The Boxed Editions are ideal if you prefer keeping your collectables neatly displayed. Both figures come in stylish collector's display packaging, making them suitable for bookshelves, cabinets and dedicated anime displays. They're also a great option if you want to collect both brothers without focusing on limited production runs.

Are the Mini Editions Worth Collecting?

If display space is limited, the Mini Editions are worth considering. Their smaller format makes them easy to arrange alongside other anime figures and collectables. You can also collect both brothers in miniature form to create a matching display without needing a large amount of shelf space.

Edward or Alphonse: Which Brother Makes the Better Collectable?

Now comes the big question. If you could only choose one, which brother should you add to your collection first? The answer depends on what you enjoy most about Fullmetal Alchemist.

Choose Edward Elric If...

Edward is the natural choice if you're drawn to the main character's fiery personality, alchemical abilities and iconic appearance. His signature red coat and blond hair make him instantly recognisable, while his determined expression captures the attitude that fans have come to love. Edward is particularly suited to collectors who enjoy colourful character designs and want a figure representing the Fullmetal Alchemist himself.

Choose Alphonse Elric If...

Alphonse is an excellent choice if you appreciate his gentle personality and unforgettable armoured appearance. His distinctive steel armour makes him visually different from many traditional anime collectables. He's also a great option if you enjoy characters whose appearance contrasts with their personality. For fans who admire his kindness, loyalty and relationship with Edward, Alphonse is an easy addition to the collection.

Why Not Collect Both?

Of course, there's another option. Rather than choosing between the brothers, you could collect both and create a display celebrating their relationship. Their contrasting designs make them a natural pairing. Edward's red coat and Alphonse's steel armour create an interesting visual balance, while their shared story gives the collection extra meaning. You could even choose matching editions to keep your display consistent or mix the formats to showcase different versions of both characters.

Our verdict: Edward wins for his instantly recognisable outfit and fiery personality, while Alphonse stands out for his unique armoured design. However, the real winner is the collector who brings both brothers together!

How to Display Your Edward and Alphonse TUBBZ Collection

Once you've chosen your favourite figures, finding the right display setup can make a big difference. Edward and Alphonse have contrasting designs, so placing them together creates an eye-catching arrangement.

Here are a few ideas to help you showcase your Elric brothers' collection.

Create a Dedicated Fullmetal Alchemist Display

If you're a big fan of the franchise, consider giving Edward and Alphonse their own space on your shelf. You could combine both TUBBZ figures with manga volumes, posters and other Fullmetal Alchemist merchandise to create a display inspired by the anime.

Arrange Your Figures by Edition

If you're planning to collect all six figures, organising them by edition is a great way to keep your display tidy. Place both Collector's Editions together, followed by the Boxed Editions and Mini Editions. This arrangement also makes it easier to see which collectables you already own.

Mix Them With Other Anime Collectables

Your TUBBZ collection doesn't need to focus on one franchise. You can mix Edward and Alphonse with other anime-inspired toys, figures and merchandise to create a display that reflects your wider interests. Their distinctive designs make them easy to spot among other collectables.

Top Tip: If you want a display that celebrates the brothers' relationship, position Edward and Alphonse side by side rather than separating them by edition. Their contrasting appearances will make the pairing stand out.

Why the Elric Brothers Deserve a Place in Your Anime Collection

Fullmetal Alchemist has become a favourite among anime fans because of its memorable characters, emotional storytelling and themes of family, sacrifice and determination. At the centre of the story are two brothers who refuse to give up on one another. Edward's ambition and fiery personality balance Alphonse's kindness and patience, creating a relationship that remains central throughout their journey.

The TUBBZ collection celebrates this connection in a completely different way. Rather than simply recreating the characters as traditional anime figures, it gives them a playful transformation while retaining their recognisable appearances. For collectors, this means you can enjoy two very different designs inspired by the same franchise. Whether you prefer Edward's red coat or Alphonse's steel armour, both figures offer something worth displaying.

They're also a great reminder that collecting isn't always about choosing the rarest or most expensive figure. Sometimes, it's about finding characters that mean something to you and building a collection around the stories you love.

Conclusion: Edward or Alphonse? Why Not Both?

So, which brother makes the best collectable? Edward Elric brings his signature red coat, blond hair and fiery personality to the TUBBZ collection, while Alphonse Elric stands out with his unmistakable steel armour and gentle nature. Both characters offer something different, and with Collector's, Boxed and Mini Editions available, you have plenty of ways to welcome them into your collection.

If you're drawn to colourful character designs, Edward could be your favourite. If you prefer distinctive armour and a gentle personality, Alphonse might be the one for you. But if you're a dedicated Fullmetal Alchemist fan, collecting both brothers is the best way to celebrate their unforgettable bond. With just 1,000 of each Collector's Edition available worldwide, don't miss your opportunity to add these limited collectables to your shelf.

Explore the Fullmetal Alchemist TUBBZ collection at TUBBZ UK and bring Edward and Alphonse together for their next adventure. After everything these brothers have been through, a little time in the tub is well deserved!

FAQs

1. Which is better, Edward Elric or Alphonse Elric TUBBZ?

Both offer distinctive designs. Edward features his signature red coat and blond hair, while Alphonse stands out with his iconic steel armour and helmet.

2. Are Edward and Alphonse Elric TUBBZ available in the same editions?

Yes! Both brothers are available in Collector's, Boxed and Mini Editions, giving you six individual collectables to explore.

3. Are the Edward and Alphonse Collector's Editions limited?

Yes! Each character's Collector's Edition has a strictly limited production run of just 1,000 pieces worldwide.

4. Can you display Edward and Alphonse TUBBZ together?

Absolutely! Their contrasting designs make them a natural pairing, particularly when displayed side by side in matching editions.

5. Where can you buy Edward and Alphonse Elric TUBBZ in the UK?

You can explore all six officially licensed Fullmetal Alchemist TUBBZ collectables through the official TUBBZ UK website.

« Back to Blog